We have a towel ring in my house which I am tenant at, which doesn’t spin in its hole and sticks up or sideways. When this happens, this is on the way of door opening path. My son opened the door and it hit the ring and it has damaged the plaster behind it. This ring being faulty and sticking sideways and being on the door way I thought this was not our fault and landlord needs to fix. Please attched photo I tried explaining this to property manager and she is hardly paying attention to what I am saying, and claiming that I should fix it as I caused the damage. What do property managers here think? Do you think it’s my responsibility to fix? If not, what are my chances at VCAT?